When Carnival’s ship called Vista first launched, it was not just a new ship, but the first ship of a whole new class – the Vista class of course. Vista is full of firsts. Some firsts for Carnival, some firsts at sea. Some invoke a wow, others more of a what were they thinking. Hits and misses in this blog are totally my opinion. Other people are free to feel differently.
Hits on Carnival Vista
Carnival Vista had its share of things to like, starting with the tube slide up on top of the ship. Carnival’s other ships all have waterslides, but this is the first one for Carnival where you slide down on tubes.
Carnival’s ships all have an adults only Serenity deck. While Serenity decks on other ships come equipped with a bar serving alcoholic beverages, Vista was the first with a salad bar. This salad bar is nothing like what you find at the serve yourself Lido buffet. It has giant salad bowls and all sorts of good things to choose from for the guy behind the counter to put in them. I say guy and not person because every time I went there it was always one or two guys working there. The bad thing about this salad bar is that it is only open at lunchtime on sea days.
One of Vista’s firsts at sea is found in the outside area at the top of the ship above sports square in the form of a peddle it yourself skyride. Although I have a bum knee that prevents me from riding a bike, I had to give the skyride a try, knowing it could be difficult for me. The view from up there is excellent and even though it wasn’t a personal favorite (mostly due to the knee) I could see why other people enjoy it. I was a bit bummed they didn’t allow cameras, but the crew people working there said people had dropped them sometimes so they had to quit allowing them on the ride. The mini golf in sports square is always a hit too.
Lunchtime in the Lido buffet brought about another first for Carnival – homemade ice cream, made while you wait. Waiting was the bad thing because the ice cream was such a hit they often ran out. There were sometimes more people in line than the amount of ice cream churned out could serve and it would be awhile before the next batch finished. For anyone lucky enough to get a bowl there was also a tray of sauces and toppings to dress it up with. They served 2 flavors each day which varied from day to day. Timing it right by getting there early or at less popular times made acquiring a bowl of ice cream easier. This ice cream is far superior to what comes out of their always available swirls machines.
Inside the ship had new things as well. Their IMAX theater is the first at sea and there’s not a bad seat in the house. They had several IMAX movies and a couple full length features. These did cost extra and there wasn’t any special deals for going to more than one movie.
Instead of putting out actual photos that get thrown away at the end of the cruise if nobody buys them, Vista had a digital photo display. They also sold the photos digitally. They did not have a printed photo option for anyone who might want that though.
Vista’s Red Frog Pub has another first at sea – an actual brewery, brewing up special beers to serve onboard.
People might think Vista’s lack of closet space in the cabins is a miss, but the reason is because some of what would be closet space is taken up by individual heating and cooling units for each cabin. With individual control for your own room instead of a central system it’s a lot easier to keep it at just the temperature you want.
Like all Carnival’s ships, the Vista has self-serve passenger laundries, which is always a hit with me.
Because of the IMAX needing the space, Vista’s atrium was just 3 stories high. While this is nowhere near as impressive as the many decks high atriums of past ships, it did have a central pole with ever-changing designs. So depending on a person’s point of view the atrium could be either a hit or a miss.
Misses on Carnival Vista
Probably the biggest miss on the Vista is the main show theater, called the Liquid Lounge. In one of those what were they thinking moves, somebody had the not-so-brilliant idea of making the theater double as a night club. Which makes for a theater with barely a good seat anywhere in the house other than the very front row. We talked to somebody who went there when it was in night club mode who said it didn’t function very well as a nightclub either. Going to a show there did not mean seeing the show, mostly just hearing it while looking at the back of somebody else’s head. Even balcony seats were hard to see from. The front row had a blue plexiglass barrier obscuring the view. The rest of the rows looked at the backs of heads except in one small section where the seats actually were set high enough to see above the person in front of you – as long as you didn’t go too high in that section because the upper seats had a view of all the lighting equipment hanging from the ceiling.
Vista had the Thrill Theater like the Breeze has, which shows short films with moving seats and other effects. This ought to be in the hits category rather than the misses, but it was missing the all-cruise pass they had for the Thrill Theater on the Breeze that made it affordable to go as many times as you want and see all the different shows. On Vista they only had the per show price, which made it too expensive for most people to see more than one or two. This definitely showed in the audience. While the Thrill Theater on the Breeze was nearly always full, the one on Vista didn’t get much use. Sadly the crew person selling tickets said they were planning to discontinue the all-cruise pass on the Breeze as well. Kind of renders those theaters pointless if they make it too expensive for people to enjoy them.
Like Carnival’s other ships (except the ones sailing in Australia), the casino on the Vista doubles as a smoking lounge. It is not fully enclosed so smoke escapes to other areas of the ship, and it sits in the middle of a public deck with no way around it other than going to another deck to avoid walking through the smoke. The casino has a video pole like the one in the atrium, which extends to the deck above. They at least had the sense to put plexiglass over the opening to keep the casino’s smoke off that deck.
Some ships have wild décor, some way over the top décor, and some more subtle décor. Other than the video poles the Vista pretty much had no décor, especially through the main hallways in public areas of the ship. It also had somewhat of an awkward layout with access to important places like the front desk and shore excursion desk limited to only one of the ship’s three stairways/sets of elevators on a deck that did not go through to the other two stairways and elevator bays.
Another thing that seemed to me like a bad idea was making anyone below platinum in Carnival loyalty status with your time dining check in for dinner at a café halfway across the ship from the dining room. I’ve never seen that on any of their other ships. If I were a new cruiser and had to go through that every night to get to the dining room I might just eat at the Lido buffet and not bother. Which a lot of them may have done because the your time dining room was the emptiest we’ve ever seen with more unoccupied tables than occupied ones every night throughout our cruise. They also had no pedestals in the dining room so it seemed pretty pointless for the waiters to perform their dance routines when nobody other than whoever was right next to them could see anything. Kind of a theme with that ship, shows nobody can see.
One thing we always liked about Carnival was that unlike some other lines that have exclusive areas available only to certain guests, Carnival’s public spaces were always available to anyone whether they booked the cheapest inside cabin or most expensive suite. Not on the Vista though. It has exclusive areas for people in both the Havana and Family Harbor cabins. The Family Harbor lounge is just in an inside area of a lower deck, but the Havana area includes a good portion of the outside area of the promenade deck. For the benefit of the few, the many who enjoy walking or jogging around the promenade deck get cut off halfway around. Our balcony looked down on the Havana cabanas and we rarely ever saw anyone out there or in their private section of the promenade deck next to the cabanas.
We used to sail Carnival more than any other line because they often have the best price and they have fun stuff like waterslides. On most ships the hits outweigh the misses, but on this one the misses were pretty overpowering. All else being equal, we would pick a Dream, Spirit, or Conquest class ship over Vista class if we sailed Carnival again. We mostly sail other lines now though because many of the other lines either keep the smoking outside in limited areas or keep it contained in a fully enclosed space.
I recently finished a 7 day cruise on the Norwegian jewel from Vancouver to Seward. We enjoyed it.
I’m glad you had a good time. Cruises are always fun. I’ve just done the round-trip Alaska cruises, not a one-way (unless I count the one that went from Vancouver to Shanghai that visited a couple Alaskan ports along the way.) Did you stick around Alaska for a land tour or some exploring on your own? The Pearl that is on my blog banner is a sister ship of the Jewel.
We stayed in Seward for 2 days and then took a coach up here to Denali. We spent a very long day yesterday in the national park. The weather was perfect plus we saw lots. Leaving Denali today for Anchorage for 2 days and then I fly home. It will be 6 weeks all up. All amazing and now ready for home.
Sounds like a great trip. It should make some interesting stories for your blog.
This was interesting! I probably won’t do Carnival again but I love hearing and reading about other cruise lines and especially the newer ships. It does seem like the”nickel and diming” trend is on a lot of the newer ships for most cruise lines.
Every ship has its good and bad and this one did have some good things. There was such a contrast between theaters. It had both the best and worst cruise ship theaters I’ve ever seen. The IMAX had each row situated well above the one in front so even a short person behind a tall one could still see, and not a bad seat in the house. The main show theater was the worst one ever with hardly a good seat to be found. When we first started cruising all the lines were pretty much the same on their smoking policies, but over time other ships have gotten less smoky and Carnival more so, which is why we prefer other lines now. The best two ships I’ve been on for that are Holland America’s Oosterdam and Westerdam, both of which had just one smoking area outside at the back of the Lido where it was easy to avoid. That’s not consistent throughout the entire Holland America line though.
I went on Royal, Norwegian, Carnival then Disney and once I went on Disney, I couldn’t go back to the others! Disney doesn’t have a casino at all so the only smoking area is outside. I think it would be hard to try another line because I think I would just compare it to Disney and I REALLY love Disney so it would almost be unfair to other lines!
I haven’t been on Disney because the cost compared to other lines always scares me away. I’ve heard they give a better price after you’ve sailed with them once, but so far haven’t found a great deal for the first one that fit in with our time schedule and where we wanted to go. Disney would definitely be my first choice for sailing with the grandkids if I ever found one that worked for everyone though. There was a Disney ship leaving the same place the same day last time we went with the kids, but we had 8 people and could put 3 people on Carnival Magic for the price of one person on Disney Wonder so we went with Carnival that cruise.
I think Disney costs a lot more compared to other lines during summer and holidays especially. During off-season times, it is still more but at least closer in price. Also the longer cruises are a better deal – the Panama Canal cruise and the Transatlantic. I think it’s true, though, that you get what you pay for – especially if you love Disney. Other lines don’t have the characters, the shows, the themed dining rooms, fireworks, all the small Disney details, etc. I would definitely recommend trying it at least once if you’re ever able to!
Oh, and the best time to book Disney is when the dates are first released because that is typically when you’ll get the lowest price, it’s like the “opening day” for the Disney Cruise season. it is about 1.5 years in advance so you do have to be able to plan ahead! Example, sometime around October 2019, they’ll release the dates/itineraries for January-May 2021. Then around Feb or Mar 2020, they should release the dates for May-Sept 2021. Then around May 2020, they’ll release Sept-Dec 2021. They’ll say the actual opening date about a week before it happens and then the booking is tiered, so if you’re platinum, you book first, then the next day gold, the next day silver, then it’s open to the public. And if you book a cruise when you’re on a cruise, you get 10% off and an on-board credit.
Thanks for the info.
How was the beer from the brewery?
I didn’t try any, but John liked it.
Celebrity didn’t offer printed photos either but we bought the digital package and loved it. I don’t like the idea of having to check-in for dinner at a different place to the MDR though. Great post.
Digital photos are more useful to most people these days, but there’s still some people who would like to get a printed copy right there so it’s nice when the ship has both options. We’re platinum on Carnival so we could just go straight to the dining room, but that definitely would have been a deterrent if we were new cruisers. Carnival does have good loyalty benefits with less points needed than most lines, but dining room access should be easily available to everyone.
Interesting read. I sailed once with Princess and Royal Caribbean, but three times with Carnival. This year was supposed to be the fourth time. But I absolutely get the point about the decor. I always loved the quirkiness of the Carnival ships, but the new once tend to be modern, contemporary and minimalistic. So boring if you ask me. We always had a great time on Carnival, but then again I have not sailed on one of their new ships yet.
If you want some way out there décor try the Splendor, assuming they haven’t modernized it since I was on it which was some years ago. That ship had some crazy things like pink dots everywhere and a painting in one of the elevators that we called naked toilet man. You can check it out on this blog: https://mycruisestories.com/2015/08/13/cruise-ship-decor-on-carnival-splendor/
Yes I actually sailed on the Splendor and absolutely loved it. That is definitely a ship with character. Love it. Great suggestion.